Below is the viewing link for the next meeting of the Hampstead Heath, Highgate Wood and Queen’s Park Management Committee which will take place virtually at 4pm on 9 September 2020. The papers for the meeting are attached here.
Please continue to send your written comments on the revised proposals for the Winter Swimming Season (summary attached here) to the Committee Chair and Clerk:
Please also note that the campaign group Forum 71 (Save Our Ponds), which is also opposed to the enforcement of increased swimming charges, is currently running an online petition via 38 Degrees which can be seen and signed here.
Earlier this week we posted feedback from the recent Swimming Forum meeting along with details of the City of London’s proposals for managing the bathing ponds during the winter season from 21 September 2020. Those proposals will now be put to the Hampstead Heath, Highgate Wood and Queen’s Park Management Committee when it meets virtually on 9 September 2020. We have again asked for a link to a live public gallery and await the City’s reply.
KLPA members have continued to provide detailed feedback on these proposals. Thank you to everyone who has written to the City of London about their concerns. Already this has made some impact e.g. cash payments being accepted for day tickets at the ponds for the time being instead of contactless-only payment. There is still much to change, and we are asking members once again to use their commitment to and knowledge of the Ponds to communicate with the decision makers.
Please find attached here a proforma email which can be used to send to the Management Committee before it meets. The email is addressed to the Chair of the Committee (Anne Fairweather) and the Committee Clerk (Leanne Murphy). It contains some of the key concerns but can be added to and personalised with your own views.
The City of London has today launched its own survey and wants to know about your recent swimming experiences, so please do give your feedback here.
Thank you for your continued commitment. The KLPA is a membership-based organisation and the input of individual members is essential.
On 25 September representatives of all the Swimmers’ Associations attended an online meeting with City of London representatives. Please find attached here the main proposals which were discussed and which will now be put forward to the Hampstead Heath Management Committee when it meets on 9 September. The Swimming Forum recording can now be seen here.
The City of London is persisting in enforcing the inflated charges to swim, despite our many pleas for them to show humanity in the midst of a pandemic and during a period of economic crisis.
Swimming charges will be collected either through an electronic wristband for season tickets or contactless payment for day charges (wristbands may be introduced for day tickets as well). Both methods give rise to concerns about privacy.
The insistence on contactless payment will exclude anyone who does not have access to this type of payment or who is worried about her privacy. Transactions listed on bank statements may risk harm to women living with coercive controlling domestic abusers.
The City of London promotes the season tickets as a cost effective option – for now. City representatives did not appreciate that the up-front payment for a season ticket, even at concessionary levels, is prohibitive to swimmers on low incomes. Also there is no guarantee that season ticket charges will be “reasonable” after they are reviewed for 2021/22.
The “Support Scheme” (the re-branded non-existent Hardship Fund used to justify the Option 3 decision last March) is not fit for purpose as the list of who would qualify for a concession is out of date and limited. For example, people receiving Universal Credit are not mentioned.
The other two Support Scheme options (partnership working and time credits) appear to be an attempt to define the deserving poor and make swimmers work for their support, in the spirit of the 1834 Poor Law Amendment Act.
The proposed free swimming for under 16s and over 60s before 9.30 am has produced mixed reactions from our members. The proposed time frame will put pressure on those trying to swim before work, and will contradict the times of day when free travel on public transport is available for older swimmers.
The KLPA has in previous communications referred to exclusion, social cleansing and gentrification at the bathing ponds. We encourage members to continue sending their concerns to Hampstead Heath managers at the addresses below, and to keep writing to their local representatives.
Representatives of the Hampstead Heath swimmers’ associations are due to attend an online meeting with City of London managers on Tuesday 25 August 2020 at 5.30 pm. The City of London has again refused to set up a virtual public gallery for this meeting (despite our repeated requests), but a recording will apparently be made available on their website after the meeting. We will circulate the link once we receive it.
Papers for this meeting were only circulated late on Friday afternoon and include the draft proposals for charging and managing swimmer numbers for the winter season from 21 September 2020, attached here.
When the City of London decided in March to introduce the punitive new charging regime, one of the mitigating factors was supposed to be a “hardship” fund, which has never materialised. Instead the City is now proposing a “Support Scheme” attached here which contains nothing new, only recycled and repackaged measures.
Both papers indicate that the City of London is continuing with its programme to make the ponds less accessible to many regular swimmers in order to maximise income.
If you believe you have been disadvantaged by the new charging regime at the Hampstead Heath bathing ponds or the post-Covid booking arrangements, due to a “Protected Characteristic” Under the Equality Act 2010, there may be grounds for a discrimination claim. This includes, for example, age, disability or religion and belief.
The KLPA has contacted several firms of solicitors which specialise in such claims and received a particularly helpful response from Leigh Day. If you think you may have been disadvantaged due to a Protected Characteristic, you can contact this company directly to find out more. If you think you may be eligible for Legal Aid, please make this clear when you get in touch. If you are unsure, you can ask about that eligibility and even if you are not eligible for Legal Aid it may still be worth enquiring. For more information please contact Kate Egerton (KEgerton@leighday.co.uk) or 020 7650 1200.
Please find attached here a letter sent recently by Sir Keir Starmer QC MP to the Chair of the Hampstead Heath Management Committee, Anne Fairweather and the Heath Superintendent, Bob Warnock. This letter follows detailed discussions between his constituency office and the current and former Chairs of the KLPA (Ruth Hallgarten and Nicky Mayhew respectively). Many other KLPA members who live in his constituency, which includes Hampstead Heath, have also been in contact with their MP.
The attached letter outlines the case made by the KLPA and the other swimmers’ associations in favour of charging “Option 2” during the “consultation” process earlier this year:Encouragement of a culture of payment by those who can afford to payMore efficient payment collection by the City of LondonNo exclusion of those who cannot afford to payMembers of the KLPA and other swimmers’ associations have been in contact with their local MPs, London Assembly Members and Councillors. We have seen correspondence from David Lammy MP (Tottenham) which was supportive of our cause and would welcome copies of replies that KLPA members may have received from their own representatives.
This targeted approach to local elected representatives is important given the anti-democratic process which led to the City of London enforcing and dramatically increasing charges to swim at the bathing ponds with effect from 11 July 2020 (“Option 3”).
To all of those members who have written to the City of London and to their local representatives we want to say thank you, and keep up the good work.
City of London Fact – The Hampstead Heath Management Committee which decided to enforce and increase swimming charges has at least two members who were “elected” unopposed to the City of London Corporation. One of those who had no competition for her seat in 2017 (Tower Ward) was Anne Fairweather who chairs the Committee. This means that nobody voted for her. Who are such members accountable to?
The Ladies’ Pond accessible shower, held together for so long with duct tape.
A significant part of the KLPA’s campaign against the new charging regime at the ponds, and objections to the current on-line booking system, has been about access and inclusivity.
We believe that the increased and enforced charges are excluding many regular pond swimmers, who had come to regard the Ladies’ Pond as a place of sanctuary. Since the City of London started to plan for re-opening of the ponds, from May 2020, we have been asking Heath Management for a copy of an updated Equality Impact Assessment. This is a legal requirement and should have been produced at the start of the planning process. For weeks we received delaying responses stating that they were very busy and were “working on it” but just over three weeks ago we were informed that Heath Management now believe that a full assessment is not necessary.
The City of London is a public body with a Public Sector Equality Duty (PSED), which includes a responsibility to eliminate discrimination and advance equality of opportunity. The new booking arrangements at the Ladies’ Pond risk excluding many women with “protected characteristics” under the 2010 Equality Act. The City cannot delegate its PSED responsibilities to volunteer led groups like the KLPA. Ad hoc arrangements, such as phoning around swimmers who are known to Heath management, are also not sufficient. The booking system itself needs to be accessible and transparent.
We asked the City of London to publicise more widely the phone number for swimmers who cannot access on-line bookings, to improve accessibility. They did not reply to this repeated request. Since the ponds and Lido re-opened on 11 July 2020 the swimming slots available have increased to 15,000 per week (over 2,000 per day). According to the City’s own figures, during this time, they have only managed to help book about 100 swim sessions over the phone. This is a tiny proportion of the overall lucrative sale of swim sessions.
The phone number has however become more widely known. It is only intended for swimmers who cannot access online bookings, and should not be abused by others. It will only be answered from 9-11am each day, with the facility to leave messages:
020 7332 3779
If you know any swimmers who might have difficulty with the online booking system, please let them know about this number so that they can make their own bookings independently.
4 August was the day Mrs Newbie came back home to Hampstead. Her wound is still healing but is nicely scabbed over and her feathers are now starting to grow back, so she was given the All Clear from the wonderful veterinary staff at The Swan Sanctuary. Her partner Wallace has been the most perfect father over the past three weeks, so attentive, so caring, always making sure that everyone is accounted for and so yesterday, Mrs Newbie returned to all seven happy, healthy cygnets.
Yesterday the whole family happily explored their pond together. Thank you to the Rangers on Hampstead Heath who did a fabulous job of fencing off the area in the pond where the dog attack occurred, and have put a small fence boundary around the dog swim area. Huge thanks to the team at Swan Support for their phenomenal help in rescuing Mrs Newbie three weeks ago.
The KLPA has been informed by the chair of another Heath swimmers’ association, the Highgate Lifebuoys, that a Twitter account was set up in the association’s name and used to post abusive content about Heath staff. The account was reported and taken down. The Highgate Lifebuoys do not use Twitter or other social media so any account claiming to represent the association is doing so fraudulently.
At present, the KLPA has no formal social media presence, although we know that many women use social media to share their love of the pond. There is a large Facebook group used by many of our members, that is responsibly moderated, but is not controlled by or part of the KLPA. Please note that any social media account claiming to represent the KLPA officially is misleading and we would be grateful if you could let us know if you spot any such activity.
The KLPA and the other swimmers’ associations on the Heath condemn any abuse of Heath staff (or anyone else). We believe in holding the City of London Corporation to account and we encourage our members to engage in constructive criticism of decisions by Heath management where appropriate via HH-Swimming@cityoflondon.gov.uk However, no one should fear personal abuse in the workplace, including comments made via social media.
